The most basic thing in every economy is the limited resources,
limited time, limited cash flow, limited natural resources, limited
land, and so on. The main reason of an economy fail is because of the
partial wastage in the resources. It same goes to the individual, we
always have the problem with not enough time, not enough money. The main
problem is because we waste most of them is not because we have lesser
time compare to the others, everyone have 24 hours per days. Not because
you earn lesser than others, on the other ways, you may realize that
the more you earn, the poorer you are. Try to compare your financial
today and 5 years back.
Let me show an example, our country Malaysia petrol RON 95 price RM1.90 today.
What
do you think? It is cheap? It is expensive? Is this price alright with
everyone in Malaysia? What will you think the suitable price? RM2.50?
RM1.90? RM1.20? Assume the cost of the petrol RON 95 is around RM3.00.
If
today I say RM2.50 is the correct price, majority of the Malaysian will
spit at me or they will open their mouth big and look at me, are you
crazy? If I say RM1.20 everyone will hooray!
Let
us think in the point of economy, not on others, RM1.20 is just like
giving people fish instead of teach them fishing. Everyone will just buy
big car, since it is too cheap on petrol. I will think that will total
waste and you will learn that, Malaysia will lose maybe 100 schools, 10
hospitals every years because the subsidy will go all to the petrol not
others and many public transport company will close down.
It
will not only on country economy, what about our individual financial?
It will drive individual to put their limited money into purchases of
motor vehicle, pay petrol, toll, car insurance and tax. The worst
situation to some people is they do not know how to use their car in
their advantage, which will be my next topic. Over subsidy will only
give the people temporary good living style, but later in the year,
people will need to pay the price. Over subsidy will consequence in the
increase of the deficit more and more every years. Subsidy in petrol
will cause people waste the limited resources, if you move on the road;
you will see that most of the car is only driver alone in the car. We
don’t fully utilize the resources that been subsidies to us.
What
about the price is RM2.50? Let me put some imagination and assume in
this situation. What I can see is maybe 10 universities, 10 hospitals
every years and more public transport company will go up. Subsidy should
go only to those taxi driver, flight company, and rural area for
agricultural purpose so on. Put aside on the effect on the global
warming. In a capitalist economy, Government should have minimal control
over the private sector, but at the same time government can be a
profit organization as well, how? By placing price of petrol RM2.50,
people themselves will have to source for others transport to their
working place, maybe they will not buying car, they will move closer to
their working place, they will take car pool with their colleague, or
maybe they will take public transport, it will cause increase in the
demand of public transport, let the public transport develop by the
private sector, at the same time, it decrease the subsidy amount,
decrease government deficit, create more job opportunity in transport
industry, let the private sector compete among themselves and focus more
on training of the driver attitude, also at the same time increase the
income of the government through tax. Subsidy can change channel to
subsidies petrol only to the rural area, to develop agricultural
industry, basic facility in rural area to increase their quality of life
and you will see more private capital will be injected into rural area.
In the end, you will see how the structure of petrol subsidy can change
not only the economy, also may help in other aspect, like when more job
opportunity been offer it will improve the criminal rate, improve the
people independent and attract more private capital to develop more
resources, especially in Malaysia with a lot of undeveloped land and
lack of private capital in manufacturing industry. If those study
Malaysia economy crash, simply because our share market is mainly
support by the foreign investors, every time the foreign investor pull
back the fund, the market will go down, just like what happen for the
past 2 weeks.
People will still
open their mouth big, saying I am government people. No benefit to
individual, let us try to analyst. Individual have 2 main limited
resources, time and money. How much time you waste in travelling with
our own car every day? Rushing here and there trap in traffic, late for
appointment. You have 24 hours a day, for kl people, most of us needed
to waste at least 10% to 20% of our time on the road. Every individual
in kl is force to buy a car; I use the word FORCE because without car
you can’t go a lot of place, correct? Now decrease the subsidy might
force you to move closer to your working place, but it force you to save
more money. If we have a good public transport that can easily access
to all area, will you still want to buy a car? Will you still need to
buy a car for yourself, another for your wife, another for your son?
Need to worry about car stolen, car parking, insurance, tax, petrol,
toll and services? Maybe you just need a family car, instead of each
person a car. How much money do you think you will save from this
scenario? With the money you have you can have your own investment in
share market, property, and live style. Again when this money goes back
to the market on the capitalization purpose or purchasing power, it will
have direct impact on our income and life style.
Whole
mindset of the subsidy needs to be change, thinking in the others angle
can change the nation. Focus more on our limited resources, stop
wasting government subsidy can be one of our contributions to the
country “since we can’t change the government decisions”. Above note is
basically my idea, do not compare or debate it with any politician in
our country.
No comments:
Post a Comment